FORECASTING
This is a hands-on laboratory exercise that offers you a chance
to learn about weather forecasting methods. There are
10 problems to be completed. If you would like to complete this exercise and
have it graded by a meteorologist with the National Weather Service, simply
mail your answer sheet (along with the required attachments) to:
Herron/Massie
National Weather Service Forecast Office
500 Weather Station Road
Old Hickory, TN 37138
Now, have fun! and take a dive into the world of weather forecasting!
METHODS OF FORECASTING
Introduction
In this exercise, we will look at some methods used in making
weather forecasts and will make forecasts of various weather elements for
several locations. In weather forecasting, a meteorologist is attempting to
predict how the weather will change during a specified period and what the
weather conditions will be during the period of the forecast. Actually,
making a forecast of weather conditions is quite easy. The difficulty arises when a
forecaster wishes to be accurate. Of course, a forecast isn't much good if it
does not accurately state the future weather conditions that will occur.
Thus, meteorologists are continually attempting to improve the accuracy of forecasts
and to accurately predict further into the furture.
To make an accurate forecast, a meteorologist must first understand what
processes are occurring in the atmosphere to produce the current weather at the
location for which the meteorologist is forecasting. This is done by measuring
certain elements (making observations) of the atmosphere; i.e., temperature, pressure,
wind direction and speed, humidity, cloud cover, precipitation, etc.
The more complete measurement coverage across the earth's surface and vertically
through the atmosphere of the those elements which affect the "weather" we experience,
the better "picture" we have of the processes producing the weather we are currently
experiencing. By observing the changes which take place to these elements over time and
comparing the changing patterns with historical patterns, an understanding of expected
future weather conditions can be made.
If meteorologists can understand how the atmosphere changes over time in response to
various factors; i.e., differences in warming across the earth's surface from solar
radiation, radiational cooling at night, warming of the
atmosphere due to latent heat release during condensation, etc., and can write
mathematical equations to express these changes, then a useful tool becomes available
to the forecaster - computer models - which can be
constructed to express how the atmosphere is changing and will appear at some
future time. The output from these models can be used as an aid to forecasters in
preparing the forecasts.
Note: these computer models are by no means perfect and should never be
relied on exclusively by forecasters when preparing forecasts. They are a tool
and should be used in conjunction with the forecaster's understanding of the
changing weather patterns, as determined from a close examination of measured
weather data to determine if the actual weather conditions are changing in the
manner that computer models are predicting that the weather conditions will change.
Major research and development effort is ongoing in improving all
areas of the process, from development of better observational techniques
(both surface systems, upper air systems, and satellite systems), development of
forecasting techniques to be used by forecasters, to development of better
mathematical equations and computer models, to procedures to communicate
weather information to users in a timely and reliable manner.
One might think of the forecast preparation process to provide users (the public,
industry, etc.) with needed information as depicted in the following figure.
(1) Observations give the forecaster information about what is actually occurring
in the atmosphere. The computer models also use these observations to provide
information concerning possible future conditions. (2) The forecaster uses the
latest observations and computer model information, a forecaster-machine mix,
to develop (3) a forecast which is then distributed to users. Some attempts
have been made to (4) control and modify the environment but more research
needs to be done in this area before it ever becomes widely used.
There are several methods used in forecast preparation, depending on the time element involved and the weather element for which the forecast is needed.
Methods of Forecasting
- Persistance Forecasting. Persistance forcasting is a prediction that
the weather in the future will be the same as it currently is; that there will
be no change to the weather conditions. Persistance forecasts are generally
good only for short periods of a few hours and become less accurate as the time period lengthens.
If it is raining now and a forecast that it is going to rain for another three hours would be
a persistance forecast. In the tropics,
especially at island stations, where day after day the weather is basically the same
because the station is affected by the same air mass with no passages of
fronts, a persistance forecast that tomorrow is going to be the same as today
is usually quite accurate.
- Steady-state or
Trend Forecasting.
In this method of forecasting, the forecaster is looking at the changes that
are occurring in the weather systems; the fronts, air masses, high and low
pressure systems, which are affecting the station. The forecast is based on
the assumption that these changes will continue at the same rate they have been occurring. Thus, if a cold front is approaching the station at 20 miles per
hour, then it will continue to move at 20 miles per hour in the same direction; so,
the forecaster can determine the weather conditions based on the location
of the front determined by extrapolating its position assuming its rate of
movement doesn't change. Similarly, if a cold air mass is moving toward the
station and temperatures at stations within the air mass are dropping at one
Fahrenheit degree per hour, then temperatures at the station for which you are
forecasting will drop at one Fahrenheit degree per hour. However, rarely will
a front move at a consistant rate of motion for 24 hours or more. Thus,
steady-state forecasting gives a good guide to follow at least for short
periods of time. Attempting to use such a method for a forecast greater than
24 hours will usually prove inaccurate. For forecasts of a few minutes to
several hours, the method has proven successful. The method called
nowcasting which refers to forecasts for the next several hours, are
often based on such steady-state techniques.
Open the meteogram image for Tallahassee, Florida.
|
Problem 1. |
This meteogram shows the measured air temperature, along
with other meteorological variables, at the National Weather Service Office in Tallhassee, Florida.
Assume that this meteogram is showing measured weather information for today. (It is actually data from July 6 and 7, 2002.)
Assume also that it is 10PM EDT at night, tonight, (0200Z on the image) and you must make a forecast for the minimum temperature for the upcoming morning. The minimum temperature typically occurs between 1000 and 1100Z (06AM and 07AM EDT in Tallahassee) assuming no major changes in the air
mass across the station. Using the steady-state method
(trend), and a 3-hr trend calculated from the temperature at 23z and 02z (units=degrees/hour), determine what the minimum temperature should be at 1100Z.
Note: "Z-time" is also known as
Universal Coordinated Time (UTC) or
Greenwich Mean Time (GMT). This time is given according to a 24-hour clock and
is the "local time" at Greenwich, England. Thus, 18Z means 1800Z, which means
6:00 p.m. in Greenwich, England. "Z-time" is always ahead of what our clocks say
here in the United States. For instance, when it is 18z in Greenwich, England, the
time is noon Central Standard Time or 1 pm Central Daylight Time. To learn more
about how to convert from "z-time" to "U.S. time"
[go here].
Record your answer on your answer sheet.
Based on the temperature indicated on the meteogram for 10Z, do you
think your "steady state" forecast will end up being a "good" forecast
or a "bad" one?
Now, consider how to make a forecast for the maximum temperature for tomorrow from this observational information. Remember, you want to be accurate. This may be somewhat more difficult since you have no trend to follow (ie, any "trend" ending at 10z only indicates rate of nighttime cooling).
Make a forecast for the maximum temperature for tomorrow and explain what method you used, either persistance or steady-state (trend) and how you used this technique to arrive at the maximum temperature value you chose.
Record your answer on your answer sheet.
|
|
Close the meteorogram.
Open the image, "TEMP MAP".
|
Problem 2. | This map shows an analysis of surface data, including temperature (the red-colored numbers).
What is the average temperature over southeast Colorado?
Suppose that the air mass causing this temperature regime in southeast
Colorado was moving southeast at a rate of 150 miles in 24 hours.
What will the temperature be at Wichita Falls, Texas 24 hours from
now? (Hints: Wichita Falls is located in north-central Texas, near the Oklahoma border. The station identifier on your surface map is
"SPS." The distance from southeast Colorado to Wichita Falls
is about 150 miles). What will be the difference in temperature
at Wichita Falls between now and tomorrow at this same time
(warmer, cooler, roughly the same)?
Record your answers on your answer sheet.
Print the surface map and attach it to your answer
sheet(s)
|
The temperature you obtained for Wichita Falls is probably not going to be the actual temperature Wichita Falls receives for several reasons.
- The air mass will probably not continue to move at the rate predicted for the full 24-hour period.
- As the air descends from the elevations of southeast Colorado (1447 meters) to Wichita Falls ( 291 meters) it will experience adiabatic warming at a rate of 1oC per 100 meters, or almost 12oC; and,
- If the land at the more southerly latitude of Wichita Falls is warmer than in southeast Colorado, the air mass will be warmed as it progresses southward.
These type of considerations must be made by a forecaster when
preparing a forecast.
- Analogue method. This technique utilizes the fact that existing
weather patterns on weather charts which resemble previous weather patterns on previous weather
charts should produce the same type of weather elements, or phenomena, that the previous patterns
produced. These previous patterns can then be used as a guide for making forecasts of weather elements.
For example, if from previous weather maps it is seen that an intense ridge at 500-hPa during the warm
months over the west coast produces a surface, high-pressure center located over the Nevada-Utah regions
and this pattern produced strong Santa Ana winds along the west coast of the United States, then when a
forecaster sees a pattern developing which has a strong ridge at 500 hPa developing near the west coast,
a forecast of strong, easterly winds at coastal stations will likely be accurate. Similarly, such a
pattern in the cold months tends to direct those polar and arctic air masses located in central Canada
toward the southeast and brings cold outbreaks of air across the central and eastern part of the United States.
This analogue method, or pattern recognition - the ability of a forecaster to recognize weather
patterns which will produce certain weather phenomena - is a vital skill a forecaster needs to be able
to prepare accurate forecasts.
Sometimes, these patterns can be used to predict the conditions for several days in advance, although
the predictions of specific conditions; how strong the Santa Ana winds will be or how cold the temperature
will be, are often not adequately predicted by such techniques.
- Climatological Forecast. This method uses such guidelines as the
average value of weather elements for a region, the maximum and minimum values of weather elements,
the most or least time of occurrence of certain weather phenomena, etc. to make a prediction of the
value of those weather elements for some future period. It is based on the assumption that the specific
element value will not be significantly different than the values of that element from previous
observations. As an example, if you were making a forecast as to whether College Station would have
snow for Christmas, then, knowing that during the 30-year climatology record for College Station
only a trace of snow was ever recorded, a forecast of no snow for Christmas next year would probably
be quite accurate. Simalarly, a forecast of no snow for Christmas in the year 2010 would also probably
be quite accurate. Climatology can be used as a guide for making both short-term, hours to days ahead,
and long-term forecasts, such as 30-day and 90-day forecasts or longer.
Open this image.
This image is a Climatic Outlook chart produced by the National Climatic Center. These charts provide
expected conditions for up to a year in advance of the time the chart was produced. Each chart normally
covers a three month period. This chart shows the outlook for temperature.
|
| Problem 3. |
At Nashville, Tennessee during the months indicated on the image you just opened,
are the average temperatures expected to be above (A),
below (B), the same as - normal (N), or unable to determine (CL) as indicated
by the National Weather Service outlook map. If the temperatures are expected to be above or below
normal, indicate by what percent; i.e., between 0 and 5%, 5 to 10%, or greater than 10%.
Note: The months for which this forecast is valid are indicated
by the first letter of each month (ie, JAS= June, August, September;
ASO= August, September, October; etc.)
Answer the same question for Richmond, Virginia.
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
Print the surface map and attach it to your answer
sheet(s)
|
|
Open this image.
This chart is the Climatic Outlook for precipitation for the same 3-month period as shown by the temperature outlook.
|
| Problem 4. |
At Nashville, Tennessee during the months indicated on the image you just opened,
is the average precipitation expected to be above (A),
below (B), the same as - normal (N), or unable to determine (CL) as indicated
by the National Weather Service outlook map. If precipitation is
expected to be above or below normal, indicate by what percent; i.e., between 0 and 5%, 5 to 10%,
or greater than 10%.
Answer the same question for Richmond, Virginia.
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
Print the surface map and attach it to your answer
sheet(s)
|
|
Below is a table giving the climatological
conditions for Nashville, TN and Richmond, VA which has been determined from past observations at these two stations.
|
| NASHVILLE STATION | MEANS |
| Temperature (C) | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
| Mean Maximum | 47 | 52 |
60 | 71 | 79 | 87 | 90 | 89 | 83 | 73 | 60 | 50 |
| Mean Minimum | 28 | 31 |
39 | 48 | 57 | 65 | 70 | 68 | 61 | 49 | 39 | 32 |
| Mean Monthly | 38 | 41 |
50 | 60 | 68 | 76 | 80 | 79 | 72 | 61 | 50 | 41 |
Precipitation (inch) | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
| Mean | 3.58 | 3.81 |
4.85 | 4.37 | 4.88 |
3.57 | 3.97 | 3.46 |
3.46 | 2.62 | 4.12 |
4.61 |
| Record Monthly Maximum | 13.92 | 10.31 | 12.35 | 8.41 |
11.04 | 11.95 | 7.75 |
8.31 | 11.44 | 6.13 |
9.04 | 13.63 |
Record Monthly Minimum | 0.19 | 0.64 | 1.18 | 0.52 | 0.69 | 0.45 | 0.71 | 0.69 | 0.28 | trace | 0.54 | 0.98 |
| RICHMOND, VA | MEANS |
| Temperature (C) | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
| Mean Maximum | 47 | 50 | 59 |
69 | 78 | 85 |
88 | 87 | 81 | 71 | 61 | 51 |
| Mean Minimum | 28 | 30 | 36 | 45 | 55 | 64 | 68 | 67 | 60 | 48 | 38 | 31 |
| Mean Monthly | 38 | 40 | 48 | 57 | 67 | 75 | 78 | 77 | 71 | 60 | 50 | 41 |
Precipitation (inch) | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
| Mean | 3.24 | 3.16 |
3.51 | 2.96 | 3.84 | 3.62 | 5.03 | 4.40 | 3.34 | 3.53 | 3.17 | 3.26 |
| Record Monthly Maximum | 7.97 | 5.97 | 8.65 | 7.31 | 8.87 | 9.24 | 18.87 | 14.10 | 16.60 | 9.39 | 7.64 | 7.07 |
Record Monthly Minimum | 0.64 | 0.48 | 0.94 | 0.64 | 0.87 | 0.38 | 0.51 | 0.52 | 0.26 | 0.01 | 0.17 | 0.40 |
|
Based on the above climatology table, answer the following question.
|
| Problem 5. |
What is the sum of the monthly mean (average)
precipitation that Nashville normally receives during the same months used in problems 3 and 4?
Answer the same question for Richmond, Virginia.
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
|
|
By knowing the temperature and precipitation that is normally received at a
station by keeping a record of past observations, such as was done to create the above table, and by having an Outlook chart, one can now have an idea as to
whether the temperature and precipitation will be above or below normal and some idea as to how much; between normal and 5% above (or below) normal or greater than 5% above or below normal, etc..
- Numerical Weather Prediction
. Numerical
Weather Prediction involves using mathematical equations which describe the
processes occurring in the atmosphere that cause changes to weather elements;
such as, temperature, pressure, wind speed, wind direction, moisture content,
etc., those elements used to describe the state of the atmosphere. Typically,
this "state of the atmosphere," or "picture," is defined by the value of weather at many different locations, called grid pints, not only at ground or sea
level, but also vertically in the atmosphere (troposphere and lower
stratosphere). The horizontal distance between these grid points is different
for different models and the number of levels from sea level up to the lower
stratosphere differs for different models. Once weather observations are made and the value of the measured weather elements are entered into the program,
the computer can then solve the equations to determine new values of the
weather elements for some period in the future; for example, ten minutes past
the time the observation measurements were made. The computer then uses these
new values to determine subsequent values at each grid point ten minutes
later. This procedure continues until values have been determined for 12, 24,
36, 48 hours, and for some models even longer, into the future. The computer
then prepares prognostic charts based on these calculated values, analyzes the
data and determines locations of fronts, pressure centers, highs and lows on
upper air charts, etc. The charts can then be printed or displayed on computer
terminals for forecasters to use in preparing forecasts.
Prognostic maps produced by numerical methods are only as good as the equations defining the processes, (and for some processes, no equations exist), the accuracy and coverage of the observational data used by the models, the techniques used to develop the model and the ability of the computer itself to accurately run the model.
It is important for forecasters to not rely solely on model output, but rather to use them as another tool in preparing their forecasts.
The maps prepared from these computer models, as well as analyses of observational information, are hanging on the 12th floor map display. Some of
the models in current use are the RUC Model, the Nested Grid Model, the
ETA Model, the Aviation Model, the
Rapid Update Cycle (RUC) Model, the Medium-Range Forecast Model.
The following links provide access to the prognostic charts produced from these
models.
|
|
The Medium-Range Forecast Model prepares prognostic charts out to 240 hours
(10 days).
Compare the NGM map and the ETA map. Look at the 24-hr surface pressure,
location of fronts, temperature forecast and dew point forecast. Notice that
for the same forecast (prognostic) time, there are differences in the two maps.
To make a forecast using these various prognostic maps, a meteorologist must
first decide which of the maps is closest to being correct.
|
| Problem 6. |
Pick two differences between the NGM 24-hr prognostic
map and the ETA
24-hour prognostic map. Explain what those differences
are. You do not have to explain why there are those differences.
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
Print these maps and attach them to your answer
sheet(s)
|
| Problem 7. |
Look at this Aviation
Model map. This map shows a 24-hour forecast of sea-level pressure, (solid lines), 6-hour accumulation of precipitation, (shaded areas), and the 1000-500 mb thicknesss, (dashed lines). Remember that wind blows clockwise (anticyclonically) about high pressure centers and counter-clockwise (cyclonically) about low pressure centers.
Look at the 24-hour sea-level pressure forecast. From what direction
should the winds be blowing across Texas A&M University (in east-central Texas)
at the valid time of this map?
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
Print the surface map and attach it to your answer
sheet(s)
|
| Problem 8. |
Look at
this site. This site provides links to several maps generated by the Rapid Update Cycle (RUC) model. Under the Forecast Time(s) column, check the box labeled loop all times. Then choose the link titled: MSLP/Winds. Notice the movement of the High and Low pressure centers and the changing wind directions during the next 12 hours shown on the five maps.
Go BACK one page and again, make certain the loop all times box is checked. Now select the link titled: Clouds all levels. Notice at the bottom of the image that the colors indicate the composition of the clouds; whether they are of liquid water droplets, supercooled droplets, or ice crystals.
Is the model forecasting for: no clouds, for the clouds to increase, decrease, or stay the same at Texas A&M University (east central Texas)
during the next 12 hours?
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
Print the first and last map in this loop and attach
the copies to your answer sheet(s). To copy the first map, simply use the left-most toggle button to the upper left of the graphic to step
to the initial time. Print the copy. Then, to copy the last map in the
loop, simply use the right-most toggle button to step to the last frame.
Print the copy.
|
- Model Output Statistics. Model Output Statistics (MOS) is an objective
weather forecasting technique which consists of determining a statistical
relationship between the element being forecast and values calculated by a
numerical model. For example, the probability of precipitation occurring at a
location during a 12-hour period may be based on the season of the year, the
sea level pressure value at that location, the surface, 700-mb and 500-mb
temperature values calculated at the location, the relative humidity values
calculated at levels from the surface to 200 hPa, or the difference between the
actual mixing ratio and the saturation mixing ratio at various levels. These
are typical element values which may be used in an equation to determine the
probability of precipitation at a location. The equation used for determining
cloud amount may use a completely different set of element values. Bulletins
containing the MOS forecasts are computer generated for various stations in the
United States and are a tool used by forecasters in preparation of their local forecasts. Since the MOS forecasts are generated from statistical
considerations using values generated from computer models, and thus can only be
as accurate as the models, the forecaster should use them only as a guide
and should modify the MOS information as necessary for local conditions.
Model Output Statistics can be presented in a common table format or in the
less-common form of a meteogram, with which you should be familiar. In a MOS
meteorogram, the computer model generated weather element values are projected
into the future in a graphical format. For more information on meteograms, you
can check out Technical Attachment No. 01-13 (October 2, 2001), written by Beth
McNulty and published by the NWS Western Region Headquarters. The title of the
article is,
"Meteogram Analysis and Interpretation".
As the numerical models evolve, new sets of MOS information become available
and, conversely, others disappear. For instance, one set of MOS data which was
based on the old LFM model is now defunct. The following sets of MOS guidance
are currently available: FWC data [based on the NGM model], MAV and MEX data [based on the
Aviation model], ETA data (based on the Eta model), FMR data (based on the
extended MRF model).
A directory which includes all of this MOS data, for
cities in the United States, is available from the NWS Southern Region
Office
|
| Problem 9. |
Using the NWS's
directory of NGM Model Output Statistics
(FWC MOS), prepare forecasts of the indicated elements for the following cities
for the days and times indicated. Need help interpreting MOS codes?
[Go Here]
Since you do not have observational data or climatological data for these locations, you cannot be expected to determine whether
actual conditions are changing in the same manner that the computer models are
expecting the conditions to change. Thus, you cannot be expected to modify the
MOS data to produce a more accurate forecast. Rather, simply use the information
that MOS is presenting.
Most of the information requested below is for a specific time
(i.e., 18z).
When calculating wind direction, remember to multiply the value
for "WDIR" by 10. For instance, if WDIR=32, the actual wind
direction is "320 degrees." This is a compass direction, with
360 degrees indicating a wind from the North, 090 degrees from the East,
180 degrees from the South, etc.
When determining the "Forecast Weather at 18z," all you have to
do is give the FWC code for "OBVIS" (visibility obscuration),
"POP06" (6-hour probability of precipitation) and "CLDS"
(clouds). Also, if "PTYPE" is listed on the FWC, indicate
the code value on your answer table. This is only a seasonal
element carried during the cool season and will obviously not
be carried during the summer months, when precipitation type
is assumed to be rain.
Once you have produced a MOS collective, using the directory of
NGM Model Output Statistics, use the copy function on your
computer to highlight and copy all of the MOS data into
an empty file (perhaps, with WORDPAD). Print a copy of the
MOS data and circle the elements that you use to
complete your answer table.
Attach a copy of the MOS
data with your answer sheet(s).
Record your answers in a table similar to the one below.
|
| |
Tomorrow
|
|
Max. Temp. |
Min. Temp. |
Wind Dir. at 18z |
Wind Speed at 18z |
Visibility at
18z |
Range in Height of lowest cloud layer (at 18z)
|
Precip. Amount (
total for 6 hrs, at 18z) |
Forecast Weather at 18z |
Boston MA
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
Houston TX
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
Jacksonville, FL
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
Richmond VA
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
San Antonio TX
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
Seattle WA
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
Sault Ste Marie MI
|
_______ |
_______ |
_____ |
_____ |
______ |
______ |
_______ |
_______ |
| Problem 10. |
Using the Forecast Weather Codes determined in Problem 9,
provide a text-style forecast for each station. Assume "CLDS" codes of "SC" and "BK"
mean "partly cloudy."
For example, if the weather codes were:
OBVIS=H
POP06=30
CLDS=BK
PTYPE=R
The text-style forecast might read something like,
"It will be partly cloudy and hazy with a 30 percent chance of rain."
Record your answers on the answer sheet.
|
Copyright © 1996-2000 Texas A&M
University,
Department of Atmospheric Sciences and Marion Alcorn.